Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ansis's avatar

Indeed, pace Biljana, migration is one of the great forces in history. All of North Africa is testament to this since they were originally Christian and now are Muslim. This didn’t happen because the Arabs visited on holiday, anymore than they were on holiday when they blundered into Charles Martel at Tours.

Make up your mind: if you do not approve of Western Colonisation, why is Islamic Colonisation alright? If you think one is and the other isn’t, you are not arguing against colonisation, as you appear to claim to be, just against colonisation by one group and not others, which is curiously the same argument as the anti-immigration forces you claim to deride.

More broadly, mass migration brings with it serious disruption, destruction, rape and misery. Yes, in time, it works itself out. Budapest is beautiful. Encountering the rampaging Huns in the fifth century probably wasn’t such a charming experience. You can hardly tell someone whose village or town is about to vanish: just lie back and take it because of the ‘irony of history...’ It is quite possibly one of the worst arguments now banging around. If you have a home, a village or a community, you must defend it if you think it has value. This is a truth accepted ALL OVER THE WORLD except in the West by delusionists. This means walls. Sure, have bridges too. You decide who comes in. I recommend excluding Hamas terrorists or anyone keen on FGM. You? Let them in? Historical process and all that?

It is remarkable that tens of thousands of mostly young men spilled over a border in a 24-48 hour period and the best you can come up with is conspiracy theories and the idea that the Spanish ought to have built a bridge, not a wall, to make it easier for them. There’s not the slightest chance if it had been the Spanish pouring over into Morocco you’d have the same view.

Rosemary Myers's avatar

Immersed in Gerard Manley Hopkins, I took a break from this immortal diamond of a weirdo poet to look/see at what had come up on my screen in the previous 2 hours. “New” substack flag — Ceuta. I’d passed over this JR flash earlier this week, now I had to relent. And dove in. My comment: So lucid is JR, so specific, so compassionate, so smart, such decency and righteousness (think Hebrew prophets, Gershon Schlolem (sic?)—to redeem this word, now so out of favor as to be unspeakable).

Ceuta — What an informative (basic facts) and illuminating piece. What an unexpectedly hopeful glimmer too I found in the fact and aspiration of a “creole” civilization. … The kingfisher flashes! (Cf GMHopkins).

Just when I’m (among many many millions more) standing at the edge of abandoning all hope!

No posts

Ready for more?